Heart Broken: Part II
I had visions, as recent as six weeks ago, that if we couldn’t be a husband and wife, maybe we could be friends. Not cordial and polite. Not mere friendly. But friends. Friends who meet and go to yoga together, who get together over coffee and talk about parenting and life. I imagined we might be able to share holidays together and still have warm cranberry bread on Christmas morning. If we couldn’t date and love as a romantic and sexual couple, we might still enjoy each other’s company, cheer each other on in the healing department knowing strong and good health is essential.
I knew in order to get there I might have to let go of being husband and wife, that to move to a place of genuine regard, I’d also have to protect my heart and my sexual health against addiction and the worry of relapse. I was not sure I’d ever be able to forgive the way the addiction violated me or ever mend the broken trust, the deep sense of betrayal given the history we had: one in which we talked openly and often about childhood trauma, abuse and the damage secrets do to souls and family systems. He led and joined in those conversations, and we had, I thought, supported each other in a many year journey of healing and recovery, individually and even as a couple.
Now I know he was lying to his own therapist and to ours. The lies, to cover the addiction, are as painful in different ways, as the disclosure of the activities he was involved in. The lengths he went to in order to protect the addiction, the places his lies have traveled are like stained blood on a white carpet. The entire rug is colored, in effect, by impact even though some literal strands and fibers have not been touched. As months passed, each awareness of what had not been true, the lie told to cover the actual truth, started to leave me feeling as though I had been battered by the past, that it was not indeed as I had experienced it in the first place.
Intellectually, I understood he had rationalized, justified, compartmentalized. It wasn’t only me who he was lying too, he was lying to his therapist too, and to himself and that the healing he was in was more intellectual than cellular.
As time passed on, awareness made me feel less hopeful, and as though more and more of the future, the past and the present had been, were and would be infected by deceit. I wanted to say, almost daily, but he lied to me. I knew addicts lied, that stupid joke about “How do you know if an addict is lying? His lips are moving” had new meaning to me. Not us. We didn’t have that kind of relationship, denial or acting out. We were in recovery.
But we had not been in recovery. We had not been healing together. I remembered how I always woke a feeling of anxiety and a nagging, “What’s wrong with me? Why aren’t I happy? I should be happy. I have everything.” I was most anxious after sex. I assumed that’s my childhood trauma, that’s the one place it lingers most, has charge. He’d tell me, “You don’t have to suffer even for a day with that anxiety,” and at the time I’d say, “That’s easy to say when you aren’t the one considering taking (or taking more) anxiety medication.”
As months passed, my anxiety abated, for the first time in my adult life. I have never had less anxiety than I have since disclosure. I had assumed that the past trauma, the post-traumatic stress disorder I had, knew I had, was managing well, had eroded my nervous system and that there would be a level of anxiety I’d always live with. When that shifted, when I realized how I felt that secret though I didn’t know I was being lied to with awareness, I grew outraged. This time, at my own self. I had trusted him more than myself, more than my body signals, more than my own alarm of fear.
I had such faith in him, such belief in his love for me, that I never questioned he had my back. Not that we didn’t have issues or problems, but I thought we were soul mates, people who would hold each other when grief hit and tears fell or who did the happy dance when life was joyful.
Early addiction recovery was awkward, absorbing and painful. Sometimes, it was even funny. But those jokes, and conversations and attempts at banter, something that had always been so easy had an edge.
Is there anyone named John in your group?” I asked one night, “Because that’s got to be hard. He says ‘Hi, My name is John,” and everyone starts talking.” We laughed hard and loud. We’d envision a Saturday Night Live skit based around a poor recovering guy who is actually named John and everyone keeps saying, “No really, man, what it is it?”
I referred to his sponsor as “binky,” once, and the first time was by accident. The second time, calling his sponsor by this name we had for our child’s pacifier wasn’t as funny. He didn’t laugh. “I’m sorry,” I said and I was.
I’d say, “Let me get this straight, you can’t order extra cheese on your pizza, because it’s too hard to assert that need and desire, but you were able to call sex lines and prostitutes?” He said, “Yes.”
When he couldn’t watch television, cuddled on the floor with our feet wrapped in each other and blankets, and our arms wrapped around each others because it was too triggering I said, “O.k., that might actually be the deal breaker.”
Some “jokes” I didn’t share with him. Once, while I looked for a part-time job, I said to a friend, “I need money. My husband can’t have sex with anyone but me anymore and I couldn’t be less interested. Maybe he could pay me for sex instead of professionals and that would help my marriage and my job.” We laughed. Later I cried. I cried because my life had become absurd, secretive and unrecognizable. I cried because I no longer knew how to be me and live in the truth of what I was facing.
My husband and I did have talks about some of the things we learned about ourselves in our own meetings and shared some writing from our journal and sometimes it was connecting but other times just painful. He’d “own” that he wasn’t thinking about me at all. I tried not to take the addiction personally. But to know I could be so back burnered, side lined and cast aside was also painful. He had always been on my mind. When we weren’t having regular intimacy I’d worry about his heart health, his longevity and feel the “bad wife” for not meeting his sexual needs. Later, I resented him for the guilt I had felt, realizing he’d probably live to 1000 if sex were the elixir for premature aging that Dr. Oz said it was.
I got intellectually that his addiction wasn’t about me, wasn’t a personal assault, but inside, though I never said to him, You are a Monster, part of me thought it. I couldn’t get past my revulsion that his fix wasn’t a needle, a bottle, food or powdery substances but other human beings, humans who were presumably of legal age but who were also most likely damaged, hurting, victims of sexual abuse and possibly even being coerced into their profession. I didn’t say how stomach turning the nature of the addiction was to me. I didn’t have to. He felt shamed by my own sadness, my grief, and also by the questions I asked. I did ask if he had ever been a voyeur, a perp and just exactly how far his addiction had escalated. On the one hand he was hurt and on the other he knew I no longer knew anything and doubted everything. These conversations, the mere fact of them, even in attempts to get clean and clear and informed and aware, caused further divides between us.
So while we could sometimes hold hands or lean up next to one another, we could never return to being a comfort to one another. He ached for me to be compassionate and caring and there for him in his time of need. He wondered if all the ways in which he had supported me didn’t count and wasn’t it my turn to be supportive? Supportive? Not only was I not the me he had wanted and hoped I’d be, I no longer felt he had been supportive because his supportive acts felt undermined by the lies.
I felt I was being generous in giving him time to get on his sober feet, by not upending his entire living situation while he was in his first 90 days or telling many people about what I was living with. The few people I confided in wondered how I could inhabit the same house. I cared about him. I loved him. I hated him and loved him. That was how. I wasn’t sharing the same bed but I could share the same house. We had a child. I worried where he would go and how he would be and I wasn’t yet ready to put my needs on the same level as his. I thought, “He’s facing the monkey on his back,” and I knew my pain was important but he was dealing with withdrawal, going to meetings, having work and trying to be an attentive father. Plus, I was also spinning. I didn’t have my feet under me yet either.
With willingness, openness and honesty and therapy and communication, would I have ever been able to be or desire to be sexually close with my partner? I can’t say. The honest answer is I don’t know. It was going to have to be, a “we’ll see,” and an “I won’t know until we are there.” I knew I would have to see, and only experientially how many of our issues were my own issues, his own issues and the couple issues. There was never a total faith on my part that we’d recover. I did believe, early on, and would often say, “We’ll either be giving talks someday at Omega about the devastation of unhealed trauma and the high cost of the sexual abuse of children” or we’d be having each other over, maybe with new loved ones, on holidays so our child wouldn’t have to choose who to be with and where to go. I never believed we’d not be friends. I never believed we wouldn’t be in each others lives in meaningful and significant ways beyond being parents.
Earlier in the process, I would still cut coupons for his favorite foods, had my daughter buy him penguin polar fleece to sew a scarf, and showed him my Shambala Sun magazine when he started meditating. He’d ask me questions about yoga postures and I’d show him adjustments to open the hip, align the spine and support or hold the pose. I’d protect his meeting times, make meals for the family even on days I was furious because I knew he was in the early period of recovery, doing exhausting and soul searching work. I’d hold thoughts or anger, when I could, if it didn’t feel I was overburdening myself.
Plus, I did see a change. Pink returned to his cheeks. He listened to more music. He was writing again. I could tell that he was out from under even though he had told me before he didn’t long to write, wrote enough at work, and I didn’t press it but I also wondered. I’d ask him once a year how he was about his writing as he had written stunning poetry, interesting plays and incredible prose. He repeated often that the work writing was his passion; maybe in his retirement when his lifestyle changed he’d do more. As soon as he disclosed, he seemed healthier, happier and unburdened. I had compassion when I thought of the cloud, the lead blanket of deceit, the fragmented self who probably didn’t want the mirror of words, who had to hide and had no one to share the truth with. I knew at the core it was a scared little boy and not a man. I had loved him. I ached for him. For a while.
And the shift, from compassion to anger happened, not at once or in a linear way, but off and on and especially after his ninety days was up and I started to realize the magnitude of his addiction. What really changed is I started feeling more compassionate for myself. And he didn’t. He couldn’t feel sorry for the way my life was shattered without feeling consumed with sobriety risking shame. I started to feel he viewed me as a danger to his sobriety. I started to understand he may never be capable of talking to me about my feelings, about the state of our relationship and that for him, that was secondary, at best, compared with recovery. I understood it intellectually but I couldn’t figure out how and where I could relate to him if I could not to be honest with him.
I knew I couldn’t make him hear, see or witness my feelings but I also knew I couldn’t co exist pretending I wasn’t mad or sad. I began to realize how we were growing further apart and that his recovery couldn’t include me. Believe me, that was a relief too. I was glad he had a huge circle of support and it did make me feel freer. I had felt bad for him, in a not healthy pity way, that while he had a super social job and many people he engaged with, he got few if any calls on his birthday or holidays from friends or family with the exception of mine. I knew he was a grown up, one who made choices, and he wasn’t the type to pick up the phone and call others. He said he liked his solitude and family time when he was home. I believed that but not completely. I did sense loneliness beyond his grief for the real loved ones lost. I also knew it wasn’t my job to make him make friends, to help facilitate, as a mother may, play dates and opportunities for connecting. If he said he was fine, I did wonder to myself and even say sometimes, Really? But not more than once.
I had two different support groups and a writing group. I didn’t need him to be there for me. But I wanted him to be. I wanted him to want to be. I felt rejected and hurt that the pain his addiction caused me and our child didn’t seem to register, or if it did, it was an afterthought.
I understood his need to be in active recovery and having laser focus and ultimate absorption in recovery. It felt, that all of the distractedness I had always attributed to work, and then learned was addiction, became distraction about recovery. He was still not terribly available or present or pleasant. It was like having a roommate one doesn’t know well, is awkward with and tip toes around. I avoided the living room if he was in it and hid in my bedroom at night. I started to feel boxed in and as though I couldn’t inhabit my home freely. I’d resent him because I couldn’t express my anger or sadness. He resented me for not understanding how my feelings made him feel.
It’s not like recovery was the first big shift in our relationship. It wasn’t. Becoming parents was. When I became a stay at home feminist our relationship changed. I wasn’t, as I had been, in the same daily flow and schedule and work life as my partner. We didn’t both arrive home having faced the same traffic and deciding to cook or get take out. The day to day of our lives had shifted and I would talk to other parents and friends about potty training, our child’s trouble sleeping, the pre-school that might be best, and the play groups. My partner and I weren’t parenting the same way. I didn’t know what it was like to juggle parenting and a full time job any more than he understood the unending hours of being available around the clock. He couldn’t understand how I’d missed work and though I was exhausted I believed our child needed me home. I’d tell people, “I’m a feminist. Child is not.”
I now know that during our entire marriage he was acting out. The pressures of parenting, the grief of losing his parents, his own unresolved trauma all bubbled up in him and I was no more available to him than he was to me in that time. In many ways, instead of the “perfect” marriage and the soul mates we had crowned ourselves as, we started looking a lot like people with those typical marriages. We’d move in and out of closeness and distance.
We had a joke that “phone wife” left nice messages, was full of love and optimism, waking like dog each day ready for a new start. “Phone wife” might call him on the way to work with plans for fun and recreation, for couple and family time and by the time he was home from work, “Tired mother” pulled rank. Tired mother was full of resentments, feeling unappreciated and resentful being home 12 hour days, doing physical therapy and special play groups to attend to our child’s attachment needs.
Tired Mother helped fuel the addict I later learned. Tired mother made the addict feel justified about getting his needs met outside the marriage, as though he were somehow taking responsibility for himself and not adding another chore to Tired Mom. It was much easier, I now believe for him to betray Tired mom than it was to lie to Phone wife and to even compartmentalize me. But, that’s just me trying to get inside his addiction and that’s actually not something I can do with any accuracy.
I can say Tired Mom wasn’t too concerned if he was feeling neglected as a husband or sexually frustrated and Tired Mom didn’t want to be a cruise director making plans for fun. I was happy to let Overworked father bond with Child and go off and nap or read or write or visit with a friend. We stopped being the most amazing couple anyone ever met though we’d often hear that’s what we were. Maybe we coasted on that description and idea even when it stopped being our reality.
Still, I never thought we’d get to a place where we didn’t speak to each other in our native tongue, getting each other for the most part, if the defenses were down enough.
Had I known, asserting my needs and being honest about my feelings would have cost, at least for today, the marriage and the friendship, would I have had the courage to go down this road? I can’t say. I had not imagined it possible. But we have, in putting ourselves first, become estranged in a way that makes me wonder what the glue was.